Welcome To Critical Literacies?

[Archive] [Discuss] [Search] [About] [Options]

The Daily

July 5, 2010

Week Six: Semantics

Welcome to the final week of the 2010 Critical Literacies course.

Monday July 5th: You will find resources related to 'semantics' in the resources area

Wednesday July 7th: Elluminate session by Susan Metros and Stephen and Rita.

You will find the link to Elluminate here. We advise you to have a look at it a little in advance of the session to familiarize yourself with it and to logon.

1PM Atlantic Daylight Time (12 Noon Eastern, 5PM London time, Time zone calculator)

Friday July 9th: Roundup of the week by Stephen and Rita on Elluminate.
1PM Atlantic Daylight Time (12 Noon eastern, 5PM London time, time zone calculator).

Some suggested readings:

- Syntax, Semantics and Pragmatics

- Basic overview of Semantics

- Putting Semantics into the Semantic Web

- Presentation on emergent semantics

- Gunther Kress, Reading Images: Multimodality, Representation and New Media

- Susan E. Metros, The Educator's Role in Preparing Visually Literate Learners, Theory Into Practice, 1543-0421, Volume 47, Issue 2, 2008, Pages 102 – 109.

Highlighted Resources


Here's what course members from around the world had to say. Want to join the conversation? Submit your feed. Then put this at the beginning of your post: CritLit2010

Network Learning: A Taxonomy of Critical Literacies #CritLit 2010
From the discussions and reflection so far in the CritLit 2010 course I set out to build on my earlier blog posts and develop my own understanding of critical literacies for the 21st century networked learner. Encouraged by Ruth Howard and John Mak i initially considered developing a taxonomy of literacies in the form of a visual model to capture the elements identified by the Critit2010 group. In considering what to include and how to represent it i started to reflect back on the course materials, presentations and discussions.

Foundational Critical Literacies

Strange as it may seem i have not seen many of the presentations related to the weekly topics, but have worked from the readings and the subsequent blog postings of others. It was good then to work my way through Grainne Conole's presentation on one of the key foundational literacies (as proposed by Stephen Downes) which came in week 1 on Cognition.
Simultaneously i was trying to appreciate the significance of what i would call the other key 'communicative' or 'signifying' foundational literacies of syntactics, semantics and pragmatics and wondering whether these foundational literacies can be worked into my proposed visual model. An example of what i had in mind can be seen is this visual model of Bloom's Taxonomy.

The importance of the other key foundational literacies of 'appreciation of context' and the 'ability to recognise and adapt to change' quickly became apparent in Grainne's presentation. Grainne pointed out that the context of education is itself changing. We have an explosion of new and ever changing technologies, ubiquitous networked access (mobile and broadband) and an abundance of free online tools and applications.Additionally learners themselves are changing - they are growing up 'digital' - i.e technologically immersed, task orientated, group based and just in time mentality and comfortable with multiple representation. This context facilitates new technological approaches that move from a content driven, transmission passive recipient model of learning to a more participative, active and social way of teaching and learning. In this context the six key foundational literacies are going to be much more important for networked learning. Grainne points out that although the technological environment in the 21st century fosters a myriad of affordances (action possibilities) for a learner - the affordances for an individual will be limited to their capabilities - i.e their critical literacies.

Grainne suggests that the technological affordances at all levels (written words and numbers, 1st wave technology - phone, radiot, tape,TV, 2nd wave technology of computer networks, mobiles, the internet) are communication, connection, interactivity and representation and that practices evolve depend on the characteristics of the users (e.g. preferences, interests, skills, context).

We can see for networked learners in the 21st century an example of how critical literacies are important when we consider Grainne's example of using the microblogging service 'Twitter". Examples of use include posting queries, commenting, gathering opinions, sharing ideas, brainstorming, maintaining social presence. We'll just consider some of the issues of using this service that were raised and how they may relate to our foundational critical literacies. Issues identified were:

i) Your 'a-ha' moment (cognition - ability to infer)
ii) is it the right network (context)
iii) your digital voice (syntax, semantics and pragmatics i.e how you communicate)
iv) Inappropriateness (syntax, semantics, pragmatics cognition, context and maybe change)
v) Personal/Private (context and maybe change)
vi) Too much twittering (cognition and maybe change)
vii) Use with other tools (cognition, context and maybe change) and
viii) A passing fad (cognition context and maybe change).

I'd be interested to hear others view on how i have tried to relate these foundational critical literacies to issues raised in twitter. At times i was not sure i could make a clear relationship. Where i feel more comfortable is in trying to align some of the practical (more tangible) literacies identified during this course and positioning these in some sort of schema, taxonomy or model that may inform the inclusion of these critical literacies as part of teaching and learning.

A taxonomy of Critical Literacies (skills) for the networked learner

I have so far collated the information below, i have put it into a semi visual format, but repeated in text format below. Still lots to reflect on, but maybe others would like consider if the top level categories need expanding/changing and what is missing from this taxonomy of critical literacies. Critical thinking skills are considered to be brought to bear on all the critical literacies from 4-7. Final thought as i write this - should these categories be referred to as skills so as not to be confused with our underlying foundational critical literacies.

1. Basic
* i) Reading/Writing
* ii) Numeracy

2. Life
* i) Management of Time, Workload and Prioritising,
* II) Self-Efficacy

3. Computer
* e.g. ECDL - European Computer Driving License

4. Web -
* 1.Managing your Digital Identity - SM
* 2.Recognizing Authenticity and Legitimate Authority - SM
* 3.Emotional and Social Intelligence (Relationship Building and Development inc trust and respect) - JohnM
* 4.Self Expression and Participation - SM
* 5.Wayfinding behaviors and Strategies in Large Virtual Environments – JennyM
* 6.Ask Questions - Think Critically! JohnM

5. Learning
* 1.Interpreting Visual Data RH
* 2.Information management - Network Student Youtube Video
* 3.Self reflection, self-directed learning (with learning agenda, experimentation & practice – JohnM
* 4.Concise, reflective expression and inquiry? . – JohnM
* 5.Appreciating the impact of Complexity Theory? – JennyM
* 6.Literacy of Memory (Storage of data/knowledge/connections –SM
* 7.Storytelling - X28

6. Teaching/ Professional Development
* to explore

7. Research
* to explore

July 5, 2010

Elluminate v. Networked Learning Conference
Heli has made yet another interesting post in her blog reflecting on the CCK08 experience following our Elluminate session yesterday in which George Siemens kindly invited us to share our research paper – The ideals and Reality of Participating in a MOOC. After my Networked Learning Conference hiatus (as a friend has called it) I [...] July 4, 2010

To CCK08 – with love
We had a meeting in Elluminate yesterday about a research paper of CCK08:  see Jenny Mackness blog for details. Forty participants came to discuss even information was not spread broadly .. we still find each other. I have followed all research papers about CCK08 course but the meeting gave some new ideas and interpretations. I’ll gather [...] July 3, 2010

Surpassing myself is not easy
Paul Bouchart was our guest on Wednesday Ellumination and I liked to participate in the session. I could follow the presentation and agreed mostly because I have a long history in adult education. It was nice to meet old models as Grow’s self directed learning that we have used in my workplace from the beginning [...] July 2, 2010

Discussion Forum

Still working on this - watch for more here

These links are comments posted to the Moodle Discussion Forum, , and . If you want to participate in the discussion, but don't want to set up a blog, then you can post here.


Post in Twitter and use the hashtag #CritLit2010 to be listed here. (These should be fresh. Still working on improving the Twitter display.)

#CritLit2010 Reading Jenny Mackness Elluminate v. Networked Learning Conference. Good post

#CritLit2010 Heli on Connectivism | & Sui Fai John Mak Nostalgia | To CCK08 – with love

#CritLit2010 #AttentionDeficit#brain http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/07/technology/07brain.html

RT @RuthHoward: #CritLit2010 #AttentionDeficit#brain http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/07/technology/07brain.html

#CritLit2010 Web 2.0 http://suifaijohnmak.wordpress.com/2010/07/05/crtilit2010-on-web-2-0/

#CritLit2010 Beyond 3r's-4th Retrieval 5th Reputation? 6th Rendering 7th Screen RT @ijukes: @lrainie Future Internet IV http://bit.ly/d35ok8

RT @maferarenas #CritLit2010 reflections | Signals of Collective Intelligence Connectivism... http://bit.ly/dhvBVQ

RT @nancyrubin: #CritLit2010 On Connectivism http://ow.ly/26Bt9

#CritLit2010 #attention -Our collective attention deficit stats?! RT @ijukes: The 1000 Most Visited Sites on the Web http://bit.ly/9llvNn

RT @RuthHoward: #CritLit2010 #attention -Our collective attention deficit stats?! RT @ijukes: The 1000 Most Visited Sites on the Web http://bit.ly/9llvNn

#CritLit2010#Edfutures#networks Jonathan Zittrain's Context-historic view first - The Future of the Internet http://youtu.be/ixejCSsXM1o

What do you think? http://inflexionadvisors.com/blog/2010/05/13/how-to-live-tweet-a-conference/ Is it a skill/criteracy? #CritLit2010

| Howard Rheingold: Rethinking Community, Literacy and the Publ... http://youtu.be/2dHCZgoLTDQ Mindfulness & crap detection #CritLit2010

New post on Connectivism & #CritLit2010 http://suifaijohnmak.wordpress.com/2010/07/03/critlit2010-on-connectivism/

RT @suifaijohnmak: New post on Connectivism & #CritLit2010 http://suifaijohnmak.wordpress.com/2010/07/03/critlit2010-on-connectivism/

This newsletter is sent only at the request of subscribers. If you would like to unsubscribe, click here.

Know a friend who might enjoy this course? Feel free to forward The Daily to your colleagues. If you received this issue from a friend and would like a free subscription of your own, you can join our mailing list. Click here.

Copyright 2010 Stephen Downes and Rita Kop This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/1.0